It is indeed a noble effort to try and seperate out things that are universally true about a plants preferences from the things that are true for a specific grower and his conditions
Joel is right that, for example, a wetter mix might seem to be a miraculous improvement for one grower with a low humidity situation, plants in a small pot or infrequent opportunity to water, but lethal for a greenhouse grower with a mature plant of the same species in a large pot
Derek is absoultely right that for that reason there can never be a magic standard formula. I guess the essence here is not actually the mix itself at all but some property of it
So, northiana is said to like inert media (I don't know, I can only dream of growing lowlanders). Should we be asking the deeper question, what is is about the inert media that people have tried that suits it. Is it rapid drainage, pH, nutrient availability, relative abscnce of bacteria & fungi in the medium? If you knew that, you could possibly have a better idea of how to adapt that plant to your situation.
Incidentally, I totally agree with the fussiness of rajah. Mine was steaming along this summer, even produced a swelling pitcher bud turned out like an upper. One day outside while I replaced the insulation on the greenhouse and the bud aborted and the whole plant ground to a virtual halt for a month. It won't recover now until spring I suspect. Good tip that you find burbidgeae to be the same.
Good luck with the experiment - the mark of a true grower I suppose. I just don't have the numbers or drive to try too many things. Everything of mine is in a standard mix and I haven't found anything that does badly enough that I am motivated to make a change. For what it's worth, my 'secret ingredient' is 50% rockwool cubes (used in hydroponics & for orchids). The theory is that even if the organic part (usual LFS/ bark/ charcoal/ perlite) breaks down a bit, the rockwool will maintain an open airy structure. This, so I reasoned, would bring the benefit that repotting could be less frequent and less harsh (no need to remove all the previous medium and damage the roots)
Dave